4.27 Retroactive Sit Rep
Middle Eastern, North African, and South Asian (MENASA) plays! I admit this is a blind spot for me. I have not read many plays written by people from or descended from these regions. Disgraced was an interesting read: well structured, nuanced, and impactful. Based on some of my colleagues reactions to the play, I understand why Talin Adadian cautioned about misinterpretation: "The danger here points to the ways in which white American theatre is able to benefit from tokenizing and sensationalizing MENASA experiences (Buck 25), but also to how MENASA playwrights walk the tightrope of representation to offer social and political commentary and to provide related rationales for their dramatic choices.” Amir is an imperfect person born into a marginalized identity that white American audiences avoid or struggle engaging with due to a myriad of biases/prejudices. Akhtar layers this contentious dynamic into the characters in his play. Instead of portraying Amir as an "exemplary token South Asian”, Akhtar leaves room for Amir to say things that could risk audiences villainizing him, such as “And so, even if you’re one of those lapsed Muslims sipping your after-dinner scotch alongside your beautiful white American wife—and watching the news and seeing folks in the Middle East dying for values you were taught were purer— and stricker— and truer…you can’t help but feel just a little bit of pride.” OOOFAS! When I read that, I understood where Amir was coming from but also recognized how fucked up it sounds. Akhtar tows that line effectively.
When teaching this play, I would need to be prepared to work with the students who read those sections of the play, and decide Amir is no longer worthy of their empathy. If I adopt Adadian’s recommendation to analyze the dramaturgical choices within the context of orientalism, I can anchor in class discussions on Akhtar’s dramaturgical choices rather than debating if Amir deserves audiences sympathy. That being said I need to better understand Said’s orientalism.
Holly Hughes!! I really enjoyed Emmy’s buried treasure. I need to read more of Holly Hughes work.
Comments
Post a Comment